Pie is the one Thanksgiving dish almost nobody wants to make from scratch on Wednesday night, and around here you do not have to. We checked every Thanksgiving pies Bergen County NJ order deadline and pickup day for 2026 against each farm and bakery’s own website, so you can pick a favorite, place the order and get back to the turkey. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, 2026, and the first pre-order deadline on this list closes Thursday, November 19.
Last updated: November 2026. Details come from each business’s own website; always confirm directly before you order.
| Where | Town | Order By | Pickup |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stokes Farm | Old Tappan | Thu, Nov 19 | Tue Nov 24 (9-6) and Wed Nov 25 (9-4) |
| Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery | Rutherford | Fri, Nov 20 by 6 PM | Nov 24-25 (8-3), Thanksgiving Day (8-12) |
| Abma's Farm | Wyckoff | Online now | Mon Nov 23 - Wed Nov 25 |
| Secor Farms | Mahwah | Online now | Mon Nov 23 - Wed Nov 25 (10-4) |
| Black Magic Bakehouse | Ridgewood | Online now | Wed Nov 25 only (7-3) |
| Butterflake Bake Shop | Teaneck | Online now | Pickup, local delivery or shipping |
| Demarest Farms, Joe's Craft Pies, A Little Cake, Anello, Carousel Cakes, Rispoli, Rockland Bakery | Various | Call to confirm | Call to confirm |
A quick note before you scroll: most farm markets pull pre-orders once the ovens are full, so “online now” can turn into “sold out” without much warning. If a pie matters to your table, order it this week.
Our local farms bake for Thanksgiving week the way the rest of us shop for it: early and in bulk. These farm market pies sell out every year, so treat the deadlines below as firm.
Farmed since 1873, Stokes Farm keeps its Thanksgiving menu short and classic: apple, apple crumb, pumpkin, pecan and blueberry pies, plus a carrot cake. Pre-orders end Thursday, November 19, the earliest deadline on this list. You can also buy a pie for Social Services through the same order page, which is a lovely way to share the table.
Where: 23 DeWolf Road, Old Tappan, NJ 07675
Phone: (201) 768-3931
Order by: Thursday, November 19
Pickup: Tuesday, November 24, 9 AM to 6 PM, or Wednesday, November 25, 9 AM to 4 PM
Order: stokesfarm.com
Abma’s Thanksgiving store has a long pie lineup: 9-inch deep dish fresh apple, Dutch apple, sugar-free apple, cranberry apple, cherry, fall harvest, pecan, pumpkin and pumpkin walnut, plus coconut custard and a crostata. Order through the online Thanksgiving store and choose Wyckoff pickup. Blueberry pie is sold in the market only, so grab it in person.
Where: 700 Lawlins Road, Wyckoff, NJ 07481
Phone: 201-891-0278
Pickup: Monday, November 23, 8 AM to 7 PM; Tuesday, November 24, 8 AM to 7 PM; Wednesday, November 25, 8 AM to 5 PM (outdoor pickup; bring your order number)
Good to know: The farm market is closed Sundays.
Order: store.abmasfarm.com
Secor reopens on Monday, November 23 with Thanksgiving pies and fresh-cut Christmas trees, so you can knock out two holiday errands in one trip. Pre-order apple, pumpkin, pecan or fruit of the forest pie, and add a bag of apple cider donuts for the morning after.
Where: 85 Airmont Avenue, Mahwah, NJ 07430
Phone: 201-529-2595
Pickup: Monday, November 23 through Wednesday, November 25, 10 AM to 4 PM
Good to know: You pay at pickup.
Order: secorfarms.com
Demarest has been farming in Hillsdale since 1886, and its bakery is a Pascack Valley Thanksgiving tradition. The 2026 Thanksgiving bakery order form is posted on the farm’s homepage; download it for this year’s pies, prices and pickup details, or call the market.
Where: 244 Werimus Road, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
Phone: 201-666-0472
Hours: Open daily, 8 AM to 5 PM
Order: demarestfarms.com
If you want a pie that gets talked about at the table, these Bergen County bakeries are where to look. Expect smaller batches, bigger flavors and firm cutoffs.
Erie’s 2026 menu is anything but basic: Salted Caramel Apple Crumb, Bourbon Pecan Walnut and Spiced Pumpkin Tahini Pepita pies, plus a Key Lime Meringue pie. Erie also offers a Thanksgiving morning pickup window, which is handy if you are hosting late.
Where: 10 Franklin Place, Rutherford, NJ 07070
Phone: 201-460-0073
Order by: Friday, November 20, by 6 PM
Pickup: Tuesday, November 24 and Wednesday, November 25, 8 AM to 3 PM; Thursday, November 26, 8 AM to noon
Good to know: Erie is not a nut-free facility.
Order: Erie holiday pre-order
The line out the door on West Ridgewood Avenue says it all. Black Magic’s Thanksgiving pre-order includes a 9-inch Double Crusted Caramel Apple Pie, a 9-inch Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie, Apple Crumb and a Chocolate Oreo Pie, plus herbed focaccia and a pumpkin loaf.
Where: 19 W. Ridgewood Avenue, Ridgewood, NJ 07450
Pickup: Wednesday, November 25 only, 7 AM to 3 PM
Good to know: Have your confirmation number ready; orders are not organized by name.
Order: blackmagicbakehouse.com
Founded in 2015, Joe’s makes 8-inch and 10-inch pies to order on Westwood Avenue. For Thanksgiving, look at the pumpkin, pumpkin praline, bourbon pecan, chocolate bourbon pecan, apple crumb, coconut custard and the much-loved key lime. Pies normally need one to two days’ notice, so call early to confirm the Thanksgiving week cutoff.
Where: 257 Westwood Avenue, Westwood, NJ 07675
Phone: 201-497-5138
Hours: Tuesday to Friday, 10 AM to 5 PM; Saturday, 10 AM to 4 PM; closed Sunday and Monday
Website: joescraftpies.com
Known for custom cakes, A Little Cake (also known as Le Petit Gateau) bakes a full lineup of signature pies for the holiday: traditional apple, caramel apple crumb, deep dish blueberry crumb, black cherry crumb, banana cream, chocolate cream, coconut cream and pecan pies, plus a fresh fruit tart. The bakery says many of its pies and tarts feed up to 10 people.
Where: 176 Kinderkamack Road, Park Ridge, NJ 07656
Phone: 201-391-6300
Order: Call, email or order online for pickup or delivery; confirm the Thanksgiving cutoff when you order.
Website: alittlecake.com
A Cedar Lane institution since 1950, Butterflake is our go-to answer for allergy-friendly Thanksgiving desserts Bergen County NJ families can share. Its pies are parve, nut-free and sesame-free. Choose from pumpkin, traditional apple, lattice apple, apple crumb, cherry, blueberry, 3-fruit combo, chocolate cream and a “crunch” mock pecan made with oats instead of nuts. Pies come in 8-inch and 10-inch sizes, and 8-inch gluten-free pumpkin and apple crumb pies are available too.
Where: 448 Cedar Lane, Teaneck, NJ 07666
Phone: (201) 836-3516
Good to know: Chocolate cream pie is pickup or local delivery only (no shipping).
Order: shopbutterflake.com
Every Carousel cake, cupcake and pie is kosher under National Kosher supervision. The homestyle pie list covers the whole holiday: traditional apple, apple crumb, pumpkin, pumpkin cheese, pecan, sweet potato, coconut custard and key lime, among others. The main bakery is just over the state line in Nanuet, and the Cupcakes by Carousel shop is in Englewood.
Where: 5 Seeger Drive, Nanuet, NY 10954, and Cupcakes by Carousel, 31 N. Dean Street, Englewood, NJ 07631
Phone: (845) 627-2323 (Nanuet)
Website: carouselcakes.com
Not everyone at the table is a pie person. Run by the Rispoli family since 1937, this Emerson Plaza pastry shop is where we go for a tray of cannoli, lobster tails and Italian cookies to set next to the pumpkin pie. Call the shop for holiday orders.
Where: 23 Emerson Plaza East, Emerson, NJ 07630
Phone: 201-265-4009
Website: rispolipastryshop.com
Anello closed its Westwood cafe but still makes its peanut butter pies to order, including the Holiday Peanut Butter Oreo Pie, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough and Peanut Butter Cannoli. Local delivery covers Park Ridge, Closter, Emerson, Westwood, Hillsdale, Woodcliff Lake, Montvale and Washington Township. Every pie here contains peanuts, so check with your guests.
Phone: 201-786-8137
Order: Anello online store; confirm the Thanksgiving cutoff when you order
Rockland Bakery is a huge wholesale operation with a retail store at the bakery, and the selection of breads, pies, cakes, cookies and bagels is overwhelming in the best way. It is a smart stop if you need dinner rolls and a backup pie in one trip, and it pairs easily with a Carousel Cakes run since both are in Nanuet.
Where: 94 Demarest Mill Road, Nanuet, NY 10954
Phone: (845) 623-5800
Website: rocklandbakery.com
First, order this week. The earliest Thanksgiving pie pre-order cutoffs on this list land on November 19 and 20, and farm markets often stop taking orders once they reach capacity. Second, save your confirmation number; Black Magic and Abma’s both ask for it at pickup. Third, plan your pickup route and build in extra time, because the days right before Thanksgiving are the busiest of the year for local farms and bakeries.
Picking up a turkey too? Goffle Road Poultry Farm in Wyckoff takes Thanksgiving orders until Saturday, November 21, and opens on Sunday, November 22 (10 AM to 5 PM) for pickups. Stokes Farm also packs a custom Thanksgiving produce box, with orders closing Sunday, November 22. For the rest of the meal, see our guide to Thanksgiving dinner in Bergen County.
As soon as possible. Stokes Farm closes pre-orders on Thursday, November 19, and Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery closes on Friday, November 20 at 6 PM. Most other spots have not posted a cutoff, so order early and confirm when you do.
Butterflake Bake Shop in Teaneck bakes parve pies in a nut-free, sesame-free facility. Carousel Cakes says all of its pies are kosher under National Kosher supervision.
Yes. Butterflake offers 8-inch gluten-free pumpkin and gluten-free apple crumb pies.
Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery in Rutherford offers pre-order pickup on Thursday, November 26, from 8 AM to noon. Most farms on this list do their last pickups on Wednesday, November 25.
Butterflake offers local delivery and nationwide shipping, A Little Cake takes orders for pickup or delivery, and Anello delivers to eight Pascack Valley and Northern Valley towns.
Whether you go farm-classic or bakery-bold, ordering your Thanksgiving pies Bergen County NJ style means supporting the farms and small shops that make our towns feel like home. Planning the rest of the long weekend? Browse our family-friendly activities in Bergen County or find a cozy spot on our best diners in Bergen County list for the Friday-after breakfast.
And if a new chapter is on your list for 2027, Michael Guarriello of Keller Williams Valley Realty is always happy to help. Thinking of selling? Start with a free home valuation. Looking to buy? Explore our Bergen County home buyer resources.
Whether a season of parades and trunk-or-treats has you wishing for a different neighborhood, or you're curious what your home is worth today, Michael Guarriello and the Bergen County Lifestyle team are here to help.
Disclaimer: Pie menus, order deadlines and pickup times come from each business's website as of November 2026 and may change or sell out. Please confirm directly with each farm or bakery before ordering.
© 2026 Bergen County Lifestyle. All content is original and may not be reproduced without written permission.
Get a FREE list of fun, local events delivered to your inbox weekly!
