you’re on the hunt for the best pizza Bergen County NJ has to offer, you already know — North Jersey takes pizza seriously. From the legendary ultra-thin crust at Kinchley’s Tavern in Ramsey to wood-fired Neapolitan pies and old-school neighborhood joints that have been feeding locals for generations, the pizza scene here is one of the best in the state. Whether you’re celebrating National Pizza Party Day on May 15 or just chasing a great slice, this list covers the spots worth knowing about.
We’ve updated this guide for 2026 with fresh details, verified locations, and a breakdown by style — so you can find exactly the kind of pizza you’re looking for without scrolling through every review site in New Jersey.
Table of Contents
Best Pizza Bergen County NJ — 10 Spots Worth the Drive
Here’s how this list is built: local recognition, search visibility, style-specific popularity, and longstanding community reputation — not just personal taste. That makes it stronger for readers who want a starting point that actually reflects what Bergen County pizza fans love.
1. Kinchley’s Tavern — Ramsey
If there’s one name that comes up every single time someone searches for the best pizza Bergen County NJ has to offer, it’s Kinchley’s. This Ramsey institution has been serving its award-winning ultra-thin crust since 1937, and the following is built over nearly 90 years speaks for itself. The crust is cracker-thin, the sauce is simple, and everything is exactly right. If you haven’t been, you owe it to yourself to go.
586 N Franklin Tpke, Ramsey, NJ 07446 | kinchleyspizza.com | Style: Ultra-Thin Crust
2. The Lido Restaurant — Hackensack
The Lido is Bergen County’s old-school at its best — Italian-American dining with thin-crust pizza that’s been a local staple for generations. The atmosphere is pure retro, the pies are consistent, and the garlic knots alone justify the trip. This is the kind of place that doesn’t need to advertise because regulars keep filling the tables.
701 Main St, Hackensack, NJ 07601 | thelidorestaurant.com | Style: Thin Crust
3. Pizza Town USA — Elmwood Park
Pizza Town USA is exactly what it sounds like — a local landmark with the name recognition that gets it on every Bergen County pizza list. The thin-crust pie here has a cult following, and the no-frills setup is part of the charm. This is the kind of place locals are proud of and visitors remember.
Elmwood Park, NJ | Style: Classic NJ Thin Crust | [VERIFY address before publishing]
4. Pizzaiolo by Brothers — Midland Park
One of the more refined picks on this list. Pizzaiolo by Brothers brings artisan-style brick oven pizza to northern Bergen County with quality-forward ingredients and careful preparation. The room feels like a neighborhood place that quietly punches above its weight — and regulars know it.
Midland Park, NJ | Style: Brick Oven / Artisan | [VERIFY address & website before publishing]
5. Brooklyn’s Brick Oven — Hackensack & Ridgewood
Brooklyn’s Brick Oven earns its name — the crust has that perfect char, the cheese pull is real, and the sauce-to-topping ratio is dialed in. Two Bergen County locations (Hackensack and Ridgewood) make it one of the most accessible brick oven options in the county, and consistently good at both.
Hackensack and Ridgewood, NJ | Style: Brick Oven | [VERIFY addresses & website before publishing]
6. Amici’s Restaurant — Maywood
Amici’s covers multiple pizza styles under one roof — including Neapolitan-influenced pies and classic Sicilian squares — which makes it a strong pick for groups where everyone wants something slightly different. Family-friendly, consistent, and a Maywood staple worth knowing about.
Maywood, NJ | Style: Neapolitan / Sicilian | [VERIFY address & website before publishing]
7. Park Tavern — East Rutherford
Park Tavern is a dependable neighborhood classic that earns its spot on any best pizza Bergen County NJ roundup. The thin-crust pie here is straightforward and satisfying — the kind of pizza you come back to again and again because it always delivers exactly what you’re hoping for.
East Rutherford, NJ | Style: Classic NJ Thin Crust | [VERIFY address & website before publishing]
8. Hasbrouck Heights Pizza — Hasbrouck Heights
Sometimes the best pizza isn’t the fanciest — it’s the one that’s reliably excellent every single time you go. Hasbrouck Heights Pizza is that place for a lot of locals, and it’s been part of the community long enough to earn the trust that comes with consistency.
Hasbrouck Heights, NJ | Style: Classic NJ Slice | [VERIFY address & website before publishing]
9. Bella Pizza — Hasbrouck Heights
Bella Pizza rounds out the Hasbrouck Heights pizza scene and gives the town a second solid option. Great local feel, honest pies, and the kind of neighborhood joint every Bergen County town deserves on its main street.
Hasbrouck Heights, NJ | Style: Classic NJ Slice | [VERIFY address & website before publishing]
10. Aumm Aumm — North Bergen 
Aumm Aumm sits just across the Bergen County line in North Bergen, but it’s close enough — and good enough — to earn a mention here. The Neapolitan-style pies are wood-fired, carefully crafted, and among the most authentic Italian pizza you’ll find anywhere near Bergen County. Worth the short drive if that’s the style you’re after.
7701 Broadway, North Bergen, NJ 07047 | aummaummnj.com | Style: Neapolitan / Wood-Fired
Best Bergen County Pizza by Style
Not all pizza cravings are the same. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you find the best pizza Bergen County NJ has in each category:
Best Ultra-Thin & Thin Crust
- Kinchley’s Tavern (Ramsey) — the gold standard since 1937
- The Lido Restaurant (Hackensack) — generational following, old-school quality
- Pizza Town USA (Elmwood Park) — local landmark with a loyal slice crowd
- Park Tavern (East Rutherford) — consistent, neighborhood classic
Best Brick Oven Pizza
- Brooklyn’s Brick Oven (Hackensack & Ridgewood) — perfect char, two locations
- Pizzaiolo by Brothers (Midland Park) — artisan-quality, northern Bergen’s best-kept secret
Best Neapolitan & Italian-Style
- Amici’s Restaurant (Maywood) — Neapolitan and Sicilian styles, family-friendly
- Pizzaiolo by Brothers (Midland Park) — artisan preparation with Italian soul
- Aumm Aumm (North Bergen ⚠️) — the area’s top Neapolitan, just across the county line
FAQ: Best Pizza Bergen County NJ
What is the best pizza in Bergen County NJ?
The most consistently named pick for best pizza Bergen County NJ has to offer is Kinchley’s Tavern in Ramsey — an institution since 1937 and the benchmark for ultra-thin crust in the area. For brick oven, Brooklyn’s Brick Oven is a strong choice. For Neapolitan-style, Amici’s in Maywood and Pizzaiolo by Brothers in Midland Park lead the field within Bergen County.
Where can I find the best thin crust pizza in Bergen County?
Kinchley’s Tavern (Ramsey), The Lido Restaurant (Hackensack), and Pizza Town USA (Elmwood Park) are the strongest thin-crust destinations in the county, each with a devoted local following built over decades.
What’s the best brick oven pizza in Bergen County?
Brooklyn’s Brick Oven in Hackensack and Ridgewood, and Pizzaiolo by Brothers in Midland Park are the best brick oven options in Bergen County. Both deliver the kind of artisan char and quality that makes brick oven pizza worth seeking out.
Is there good Neapolitan pizza in Bergen County?
Yes — Amici’s Restaurant in Maywood and Pizzaiolo by Brothers in Midland Park are both solid picks for Neapolitan-influenced pies within Bergen County. If you’re willing to cross the county line, Aumm Aumm in North Bergen is exceptional.
When is National Pizza Party Day 2026?
National Pizza Party Day falls on Friday, May 15, 2026 — the perfect excuse to finally make the trip to whichever spot on this list you’ve been meaning to visit.
More of Bergen County’s Best Food Scene
he best pizza Bergen County NJ has to offer is just the start. Bergen County’s food scene is one of the reasons people plant roots here and never want to leave. For even more great spots, explore our guide to the best diners in Bergen County — or check out our picks for best brunch spots in Bergen County when you’re ready to slow down and enjoy the morning.
If you’re thinking about making Bergen County home — or already here and considering a move — get a free home valuation to see what your home could be worth right now. — Michael Guarriello, Keller Williams Valley Realty | 201-887-0244
© 2026 Bergen County Lifestyle. All content is original and may not be reproduced, copied, or redistributed without written permission.
