Table of Contents
Planning your Thanksgiving feast? Skip the stress of baking and support Bergen County’s amazing local small businesses! These Thanksgiving bakeries Bergen County offers are ready to help you create an unforgettable holiday spread. Here’s your complete pie order Bergen County guide with everything you need to pre-order from the best local bakeries.
1. Traditional Thanksgiving Bakeries Bergen County
Goffle Road Poultry Farm
Address: 549 Goffle Road, Wyckoff, NJ 07481
Phone: (201) 444-3238
Website: gofflepoultry.com
A Bergen County institution since 1948, Goffle Road is legendary for both fresh turkeys and exceptional pies with flaky, buttery crusts and generous fruit fillings. Pick up your pie when you grab your turkey for ultimate Thanksgiving convenience.
Pies & Goods: Classic pumpkin pie, Dutch apple pie, pecan pie, apple crumb pie, chicken pot pies
Butterflake Bake Shop
Address: 448 Cedar Lane, Teaneck, NJ 07666
Phone: (201) 836-3516
Website: butterflake.com
A family-owned kosher bakery since 1947 bringing old-school quality with recipes handed down through generations. Everything is made from scratch and completely nut-free, featuring impossibly flaky crusts made with real butter.
Pies & Goods: Pumpkin pie, sweet potato pie, apple pie, cherry pie, pecan pie, babka, coffee cakes, cookies, pastries
Demarest Farms
Address: 244 Wierimus Road, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
Phone: (201) 666-0472
Website: demarestfarms.com
Operating since 1886, this beloved farm market offers farm-to-table pies made with locally sourced ingredients, including their own apples. The country store atmosphere makes picking up your order a true fall experience.
Pies & Goods: Apple pie (farm-grown apples), pumpkin pie, apple cider donuts, fresh baked goods, fruit pies
Stokes Farm
Address: 23 De Wolf Road, Old Tappan, NJ 07675
Phone: (201) 768-3931
Website: stokesfarm.com
A 6th generation family farm with over 150 years of farming experience! Known for sustainable farming practices and organic methods, Stokes Farm brings farm-to-table quality to their fresh-baked goods and legendary apple cider donuts.
Pies & Goods: Apple pies (farm-grown apples), seasonal pies, apple cider donuts, baked goods, fresh produce
Secor Farms
Address: 168 Airmont Avenue, Mahwah, NJ 07430
Phone: (201) 529-2595
Website: secorfarms.com
A farm for all seasons located at the northern Bergen County border! Secor Farms has been a local treasure offering fresh produce, baked goods, and seasonal activities. Their farm market carries fresh apple cider, homemade donuts, and pies during fall.
Pies & Goods: Fresh fruit pies, homemade donuts, fresh-pressed apple cider, seasonal baked goods
2. Artisan & Specialty Thanksgiving Bakeries Bergen County
Joe’s Craft Pies
Address: 257 Westwood Avenue, Westwood, NJ 07675
Phone: (201) 497-5138
Website: joescraftpies.com
This small-batch bakery specializes in handmade pies with homemade quality using fresh ingredients. Their amazing crusts keep customers coming back, and the Key Lime pie is legendary.
Pies & Goods: Key Lime pie, pecan pie, apple pie, praline apple pie, lemon buttermilk pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, chicken pot pies, quiches
Pies & Quiches
Address: 311 Market Street, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663
Phone: (201) 746-6251
Website: piesquiches.com
Everything at this specialty bake shop is made from scratch with quality ingredients. Owner Karen Trento-Allenstein bakes on three simple principles: fresh, from scratch, and with quality ingredients. Orders accepted by phone only.
Pies & Goods: Sweet and savory pies, asiago quiche, lemon chess pie, variety of quiches, whoopie pies, lemon bars, key lime bars, brownies, scones
Rispoli Pastry Shop
Address: 56 Kinderkamack Road, Emerson, NJ 07630
Phone: (201) 265-1110
Website: rispolipastry.com
Recently named one of New Jersey’s best bakeries with the “state’s best sfogliatelle and lobster tail,” this Italian bakery brings European excellence to traditional American pies. Family-owned and operated with exceptional quality.
Pies & Goods: Traditional pies, sfogliatelle, lobster tails, Italian pastries, cookies, custom cakes
Rispoli Pastry Shop
Address: 56 Kinderkamack Road, Emerson, NJ 07630
Phone: (201) 265-1110
Website: rispolipastry.com
Recently named one of New Jersey’s best bakeries with the “state’s best sfogliatelle and lobster tail,” this Italian bakery brings European excellence to traditional American pies. Family-owned and operated with exceptional quality.
Pies & Goods: Traditional pies, sfogliatelle, lobster tails, Italian pastries, cookies, custom cakes
3. Just Outside Bergen County (Worth the Short Drive!)
Carousel Cakes
Address: 5 Seeger Drive, Nanuet, NY 10954
Phone: (845) 627-2323
Website: carouselcakes.com
Featured as Oprah’s favorite Red Velvet cake! This gourmet wholesale bakery outlet has been a family tradition for over 50 years. All products are Kosher and made with natural, fresh ingredients. They also have Cupcakes by Carousel in Englewood, NJ.
Pies & Goods: Chocolate cakes, cheesecakes, pies (including parve apple pie), Red Velvet cake, 40+ varieties of gourmet cupcakes
Rockland Bakery
Address: 94 Demarest Mill Road, Nanuet, NY 10954
Phone: (845) 623-5800
Website: rocklandbakery.com
An absolute must-visit! This factory bakery lets you pick fresh bread right off the conveyor belt as it comes out of the oven. With incredible aroma and huge selection, Rockland Bakery supplies many top NYC restaurants.
Pies & Goods: Fresh-baked pies, pastries, cakes, cookies, artisan breads, bagels, gluten-free options
Support Bergen County Small Businesses
When you place your pie order Bergen County at local bakeries, you’re supporting family-owned businesses that have served our community for generations. Small Thanksgiving bakeries Bergen County put genuine care into every hand-crafted dessert with real ingredients—that difference shows up in every delicious bite.
Ready to order? Start calling these amazing Thanksgiving bakeries Bergen County now to secure your holiday desserts. Your family will rave about dessert, and you’ll feel great supporting our local community!
If you’re looking to joining a run or walk as a new Thanksgiving tradition, check out this “Upcoming Turkey Trots in Bergen County, NJ – Thanksgiving 2025“
